Countering advanced persistent threats (APTs) and cyber threat actors (CTAs) has contextualized the ever-evolving landscape of counterintelligence (CI). Offensive cyber counterintelligence (OCCI) has clearly emerged as a critical component in the CI arsenal. A comprehensive understanding of OCCI’s effectiveness in addressing threats posed by APTs/CTAs remains elusive. This breakout aims to fill intelligence gaps in the digital threat landscape by examining the multifaceted variables and dynamics of OCCI. While OCCI is a crucial mechanism in the field of intelligence, there is a lack of research that systematically assesses the interplay between key variables influencing the efficacy of OCCI. What impact do attribution accuracy, operational timing, deterrence effectiveness, repercussions against the accused entity, and tactical adaptations have on the success of offensive cyber counterintelligence (OCCI) strategies against Advanced Persistent Threats (APTs) and Cyber Threat Actors (CTAs)? The breakout aims to provide nuanced insights that go beyond singular dimensions of CI. Further refining OCCI strategies will provide meaningful insight for policy decisions.